ѨƵ

Financial Planning

The key to financial planning is tostart.

Whether you’re looking to create your first financial plan or want a second opinion on one you already have, it’s free to talk.

Capital Gains Tax on Mutual Funds: Not as Bad as You Think

It's all about how mutual funds are structured.

Article published: March 06, 2025

Have you ever received a tax notice claiming you made money from a mutual fund, even though the fund lost value? It might seem confusing – even unfair – but this scenario is more common than you think. While it’s one of the biggest frustrations for mutual fund investors, there’s good news: Paying capital gains tax on mutual funds isn’t as bad as it seems. Let’s break it down and explore why this process may actually work in your favor.

What Are Capital Gains Taxes?

Capital gains taxes are the taxes you pay on the profit earned when selling an asset, such as stocks, mutual funds or real estate, for more than its purchase price. These taxes are categorized as either short term (for assets held one year or less, taxed at regular income rates) or long term (for assets held more than one year, taxed at lower rates). In the case of mutual funds, you may owe capital gains taxes even if you don’t sell your shares, as funds can generate taxable gains through their trading activities.

Example Scenario: Investing in Stock

As an example, say you invest $10,000 in a stock and it rises to $30,000. As you know, if you don’t sell the stock, there is no tax. But if you do sell the stock, you have to pay a tax on the profit, or “capital gain.” You can delay this tax for years – even decades – by holding onto your shares, because you don’t pay capital gains tax until you sell (assuming the asset appreciated).

This tax rule applies to mutual funds a little bit differently. You buy shares of a fund and the fund, in turn, buys stocks. If you sell your shares of the fund for a profit, you incur capital gains, just as if you had sold shares of the stock (as noted above).

Why You May Owe Taxes Even When the Fund Loses Money

But keeping your shares in the fund doesn’t necessarily mean no taxes. Why? Because the fund might sell some of the stock it owns. If the fund does this, it incurs a capital gain. And since you are the real owner of the fund, you are the one who has to pay the capital gains tax on the mutual fund. That’s why the fund distributes Form 1099-DIV to reveal your share of the capital gains incurred.

Example Scenario: Taxable Gains in a Losing Fund

If the fund sells shares of any of the stocks it owns, those sales trigger the capital gain – even though you have not sold any of your shares of the fund. But how can a fund incur a capital gain if it has lost money? Say you invest in a fund that’s 10 years old. You pay $10 for each share. At the end of the year, your fund’s share price is only $8 – meaning you’ve lost money. But soon after, you receive Form 1099-DIV in the mail declaring that you have capital gains of several thousand dollars. How can this be?

You may have purchased fund shares at $10 each. However, the fund itself owns stocks purchased years ago. It has now sold some of those stocks for a profit. Thus, even though you didn’t enjoy that profit, the fund you own did, and, as a shareholder, you must now pay your share of the taxes on that capital gain.

The Long-Term Benefits of Prepaid Capital Gains Taxes

Now here’s why paying capital gains tax on mutual funds isn’t so bad. When you sell your shares in the fund, the tax you will be required to pay at that time will be lower than it otherwise would have been because you have, in essence, prepaid your tax.And if you sell your fund for a loss (and do not violate the ), you can use those losses to offset capital gains – up to $3,000 against income – and carry forward the rest.

How Reinvesting Capital Gains Benefits Fund Investors

Mutual fund shareholders pay a portion of their capital gains taxes each year, while stock investors typically pay all their taxes at once when they sell their shares. At first glance, it might seem like stock investors have an advantage because delaying taxes allows their money to grow without interruption.

However, this isn’t necessarily the case. Most mutual fund investors reinvest their capital gains distributions into additional shares, which can lead to more effective compounding over time. This reinvestment strategy allows mutual fund investors the opportunity to grow their wealth steadily.

When it’s time to sell, mutual fund investors can benefit from a smaller tax bill. Since they’ve already paid some or most of their capital gains taxes incrementally, the final amount owed is typically much lower than expected, providing an added financial advantage.

Take a Long-Term Approach to Wealth Management

While it may be a nuisance to pay capital gains tax on your mutual funds in the short term, we here at ѨƵ focus on the long-term strategy. Our advisors are always willing to have a conversation with you to help determine the best wealth management strategy for your situation.

The information provided is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, legal or tax advice; an offer to buy or sell any security or insurance product; or an endorsement of any third party or such third party's views. The information contained herein has been obtained from sources we believe to be reliable but is not guaranteed as to its accuracy or completeness.

Neither ѨƵ nor its affiliates offer tax or legal advice. Interested parties are strongly encouraged to seek advice from your qualified tax and/or legal professionals to help determine the best options for your particular circumstances.

AM4146135


Need more help?

Set up a free meeting and get guidance tailored to your unique circumstances.